Sunday, April 24, 2011
Investing in Growth Themes Part 1
At its current price, Apple's market capitalisation is about US$320 billion, and few companies are larger. Google Finance puts Apple's historical PE at 16.72X, not an expensive multiple of earnings, while the company's latest earnings blowout suggests that valuations are likely to fall further, should the company's explosive growth continue. Also, the macro-picture for Apple appears extremely favourable, considering the huge shift towards mobile computers like the iPad. Coupled with the relatively untapped emerging markets, the growth possibilities are enormous. Is Apple the sure-fire way to tap on an unstoppable growth theme?
Before we get ahead of ourselves, history offers an alternate opinion. The automobile was a revolutionary invention which changed the way people travelled. However, few investors made money investing in this "sure" trend, and the 2008-2009 crisis even saw the collapse of the "venerable" General Motors, a member of the Dow Jones Industrial Average since 1915. Many automobile companies have collapsed, leaving investors much poorer, even though the industry has boomed (if the number of automobiles on the roads is a measure of the industry's success). Warren Buffett has been quoted to say that the best way to invest in the automobile industry would have been to short the stocks of horse-drawn carriage companies.
Similarly, the airline industry revolutionised long-distance travel, but investments in airline companies has been generally fared poorly in comparison to the growth in the sector. Engine and aircraft manufacturers were the beneficiaries of the sector's boom, while the airline operators saw shrinking margins as competition intenstified. Many airlines also went bust despite the astronomical growth in air travel over the years.
What does this tell us about investing in the next major growth trend? We could take an appathetic approach and ignore the growth trend (which has not generally not resulted in poor investment returns, if one considers both the airline industry as well as the automobile makers). Alternatively, we could seek investment opportunities that ride on the trend - we are looking for the horse-drawn carriage companies to short, the Boeings and Airbuses which benefit directly rom a trend, but maintain pricing power, or the indirect beneficiaries like the Exxons and Shells, which drill and refine oil needed to power the increasing number of vehicles on the road.
Given all this, how then does one ride the growth trend of "portable new media"? We will highlight two themes that may benefit from this growth trend in our next post.
Sino Techfibre - Fraudulent Fire?
How convenient. The company's stock was halted for trading on 13 April, after auditors raised issues over the legitimacy of invoices. Now, the financial records to "verify" those invoices (likely to be "receivables" on the company's books) will most probably be lost in the fire, rendering an audit impossible.
This latest incident only serves to highlight the poor quality of S-Chips listed on the Singapore Exchange, something which has kept us from investing in the sector despite having bombed-out valuations. When balance sheets cannot be trusted, it is impossible to ascertain the true value of a company, and the track record of the sector in terms of corporate governance has been attrocious. In academic terms, the "risk premium" attributed to an investment in the S-Chip sector should be extremely high, which goes a long way in explaining the ridiculously-low valuations of most companies in the sector. We sympathise with investors who have fallen prey to these poorly managed companies and will continue to seek value opportunities outside of the S-Chip sector.
Sunday, February 27, 2011
Further pain in the S-Chip sector; China Hongxing and Hongwei both suspended
We have highlighted our concerns over S-Chips in the past (see http://sgvalue.blogspot.com/2010/09/looking-at-cash-balances-of-s-chips.html and http://sgvalue.blogspot.com/2010/06/s-chipped-reprise-2010.html) and the latest audit problems in the case of Hongwei and China Hongxing serve to showcase that S-Chip companies are indeed poor quality companies which cannot be assessed based on balance sheet strength alone. We do not own any S-Chips and will continue to adopt a sceptical approach towards the sector, which is fraught with fraud (pun not intended).
Monday, October 25, 2010
SGX to merge with ASX, to take on debt
Under the terms of the Scheme, ASX shareholders as at a record date to be determined will be paid, in relation to each ASX Share, a combination of:
• A$22.00 (approximately S$28.04) in cash (the “Cash Consideration”); and
• 3.473 new SGX Shares (the “Share Consideration”).
The aggregate value of the Share Consideration is S$5.8 billion (approximately A$4.6 billion), based on the last traded price of SGX Shares as at the Latest Practicable Date, and S$5.8 billion (approximately A$4.6 billion), based on the volume-weighted average price (“VWAP”) of SGX Shares transacted on the Latest Practicable Date.
Accordingly, the value of the aggregate consideration payable for the Proposed Combination (the “Scheme Consideration”), based on the aggregate Cash Consideration and the aggregate value of the Share Consideration (determined by reference to the last traded price of SGX Shares as at the Latest Practicable Date), is approximately A$8.4 billion (approximately S$10.7 billion), or approximately A$48.00 approximately S$61.17) for each ASX Share.
The value of the Scheme Consideration based on the aggregate Cash Consideration and the aggregate value of the Share Consideration (determined by reference to the VWAP of SGX Shares transacted on the Latest Practicable Date), is approximately A$8.4 billion (approximately S$10.8 billion).
The move will see SGX coughing up about S$4.9 billion in cash, which will inevitably see the combined entity take on between S$3-4 billion in debt. Depending on the cost of debt, we estimate that interest could cost SGX as much as $150 million a year, which will eat into earnings (and dividends!).
We have maintained that SGX looks terribly expensive at current levels, and it is fantastic that management can utilise the expensive stock to purchase a choice asset (ASX in this case) to benefit shareholders. However, the deal would have made much more sense if an all-stock offer was utilised. By offering cash and taking on debt, it appears that the EPS-accretion (as SGX touts the deal to be, EPS of $0.3008 to $0.3612) will be difficult to achieve after factoring in interest payments.
Tuesday, October 19, 2010
Asset bubbles forming in Asia? Not yet, but early indications are there
The current situation: while developed economies (most notably the US) are required to keep interest rates low to stimulate their domestic economies, the emerging markets (and Asia in particular) are booming once again. Output is at record-high levels, while consumers on the ground hardly feel the recessionary chill of the Western world.
A quick look around us in Singapore emphasises this: Bustling car showrooms, packed shopping malls, an extremely tight labour market (a JobsDB email I receive daily highlighting jobs in the financial sector is noticeably longer, compared to a year ago). The IPO market is booming once again, with the latest IPO of GIobal Logistic Properties 12 times subscribed, and Mapletree Industrial Trust set to join in the fray. These are all indications that sentiment is turning positive again, with the STI recently climbing to new 2-year highs.
With Asia and Emerging Markets the obvious forerunners in the post-Lehman world, investors in the US are more than happy to borrow at near-zero rates to participate in the tremendous growth opportunities in the emerging market regions. The expected appreciation of Asian currencies is an added bonus, and also the result of strong inflows of capital into the region. Singapore recently tightened monetary policy further, which will add to upward pressure on the SGD against the USD.
As with all asset bubbles, the flight of capital will be swift, and many investors will be left nursing their wounds in the aftermath. Fortunately, stock market valuations still appear fair at the moment, despite the onslaught of new capital inflows from the West into Asia. Several segments of the Asian stock market appear slightly expensive (Indonesian and Indian equities, consumer discretionary stocks in China and India, as well as hospitality/leisure plays in Singapore), but the overall market is generally fairly valued at present. We will maintain our exposure to the stock market within the portfolio, but will be keenly watching out for bubble-like symptoms which we expect to develop at some stage over the next few years.
Foreclosed Homeowners Break Into Former Home
CNBC.com Article: Foreclosed Homeowners Break Into Former Home
The investors sold the home, but before the new owner could move in, the Earls had the locks changed and moved back in themselves. "Why should we lay down?" she says her husband asked her. "We need to fight back."
Full Story:
http://www.cnbc.com/id/39726698
--------------------------------
Foreclosure woes have hit US bank stocks (and notably our holding in WFC) as investors worry that banks will have problems evicting homeowners due to a lack of proper paperwork.
It appears ridiculous that some homeowners believe they should be allowed to stay in their homes after failing to service their mortgages, on the basis of legal technicalities. If the courts ultimately rule that banks cannot foreclose the majority of properties due to improper paperwork, we may be looking at mass mayhem. Why should anyone pay their mortgages then?
More likely, some punitive action will be taken on improper bank practices. People who have borrowed money to buy a home MUST service their mortgage; there is no free lunch here
Thursday, September 30, 2010
Looking at cash balances of S-Chips just ain't enough
"Microsoft intends to use the net proceeds from the offering for general corporate purposes, which may include funding for working capital, capital expenditures, repurchases of stock and acquisitions." - Microsoft.com
Monday, September 20, 2010
Jardine Strategic, the one that got away
- Never sell higher conviction ideas; always start with the lowest conviction stocks
Monday, August 23, 2010
U.S. Banks: Goldman Sachs Lowers Targets for Bank Earnings - CNBC
Bought 150 more shares of Wells Fargo & Co. on 20th Aug at US$24.3899 per share, for a total consideration of US$3,658.48. The stock is trading near its 52-week low and also near book value on the back of recent market weakness. WFC has been exceptionally battered, with Goldman Sachs recently citing "higher-than-average" yields on its security portfolio, which are expected to normalise over the next few years (to half the current 6+% yield). While this may be alarming news, the actual numbers are less dramatic. Based on the 2Q10 financial statement, about US$16.2 billion of securities in WFC's portfolio were earning excessively high interest of 6.48%, an insignificant percentage (just 1.5%) of WFC's total "earning assets" (US$1.069 trillion).
Wednesday, June 16, 2010
"S-Chipped" (Reprise) 2010
Wednesday, June 9, 2010
Sold SGX, a quarter of the portfolio in cash
Monday, June 7, 2010
Sold Jardine Strategic, market technicals unfavourable
Liew Mun Leong eats his own cooking
Thursday, June 3, 2010
Mermaid Maritime extends contract for MTR-2
While the day rate was not up substantially, it is comforting to know that Chevron's contract has been extended. MTR-1 remains a disappointment, having not secured any work since September 2009, and the 6-month lull period anticipated by the management has been too optimistic a scenario. However, a third rig (KM-1, 75% owned by Mermaid) is slated for delivery this year (after originally scheduled for a 4Q 09 delivery), and will be contracted for 5 years drilling for Petronas.
Tuesday, June 1, 2010
WBL's 1H '10 profit up 93% to $40 million, declares 5 cent interim dividend
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
Euro-led slow down, tensions in Korea, can it get any worse?
- A Euro-led global slowdown, leading to a double-dip global recession
- Issues related to the Euro area: a potential debt default by one of the PIIGs, a break-up of the Euro-zone, uncertainty over European bank balance sheets, systemic meltdown of the global financial system (ie. Lehman's 2008 failure)
- War breaking out on the Korean peninsula
- Chinese asset bubble/tightening worries
- A (largely benign) financial reform bill being passed in the US, and perhaps, the potential impact of Basel III on financial institutions
- Sell-side analysts need to turn very bearish (consensus estimates for most markets are still on the rise)
- GDP estimates need to be revised downwards (like market earnings estimates, still on the rise)
- A "haircut" taken by holders of PIIGs debt, possibly beginning with Greek debt
Tuesday, April 20, 2010
Third Avenue Management LLC nominates WBL director
"Mr Duster is nominated by Third Avenue Management LLC, a substantial shareholder of the Company. The Nominating Committee of the Company reviewed his nomination and based on his qualifications and experience, recommended his appointment to the Board of Directors. "
Monday, April 19, 2010
Gloucester-Macarthur merger: Noble shareholders vote "No"
"Noble Group wishes to announce that the merger proposal between Macarthur and Gloucester was soundly defeated by shareholders in a vote held in Hong Kong at 2.30pm today."
Sharebuilder purchases for today (19 Apr 2010):
32 shares of STI ETF at $2.9989, 20 shares of Fraser and Neave at $4.84
Tuesday, April 13, 2010
Euphoria, but not in the stock market....yet
- Skyrocketing COE prices (but maybe just a manifestation of the "kiasu-ism" on the reduction in availability)
- An increasingly excited domestic property market (just count the huge number of ads in the Saturday edition of the Straits Times)
- A huge number of IPOs (11 so far this year, and we're only in April)
- High over-subscription for IPOs (CACHE's placement tranche was 7.2X subscribed, while the public tranche was about 20X subscribed)
- A disconnect between large cap and small cap stock price movements (small cap stocks have recently found favour)